Heat Pump vs Furnace: Running Cost Comparison
A heat pump is two to three times more efficient than a furnace, but efficiency is not the same as cost — the price of gas versus electricity decides the winner.
Verdict
In mild and moderate climates, a heat pump usually costs less to run. Below roughly 25–30°F, or where gas is very cheap and electricity very expensive, a gas furnace can win on operating cost.
Efficiency is not cost
A heat pump delivers two to four units of heat per unit of electricity (COP 2–4). A 90% AFUE furnace delivers 0.9 units per unit of gas. On paper the heat pump is far ahead — but gas usually costs less per unit of energy than electricity, so the comparison has to be done in dollars, not in efficiency percentages.
| System | Efficiency | Fuel price | Cost per 100k BTU |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat pump, mild weather (COP 3.0) | 300% | 18¢/kWh | ≈ $1.76 |
| Heat pump, cold weather (COP 2.0) | 200% | 18¢/kWh | ≈ $2.64 |
| Gas furnace (90% AFUE) | 90% | $1.20/therm | ≈ $1.33 |
| Gas furnace (80% AFUE) | 80% | $1.20/therm | ≈ $1.50 |
The crossover temperature
As outdoor air gets colder, a heat pump’s COP falls. Modern cold-climate units hold up well to 5°F, but the cost per BTU rises. Where gas is cheap, the crossover can land around 25–30°F; where gas is expensive or unavailable, the heat pump wins all winter. This is why the same equipment advice is correct in Georgia and wrong in parts of the Midwest.
Costs the running comparison ignores
- Installation: heat pumps cost more up front, and may require electrical and duct work.
- Lifespan: furnaces typically last longer than heat pumps.
- Cooling: a heat pump also replaces the air conditioner, which changes the total math.
- Rebates: federal and utility incentives tilt the installed cost toward heat pumps in many states.
Frequently asked questions
Is a heat pump cheaper than gas heat?
Usually in mild climates and in high-gas-price regions. In cold climates with cheap gas, a furnace can still be cheaper to run.
At what temperature does a heat pump stop being efficient?
Efficiency declines gradually rather than stopping. Cold-climate units still run at 5°F, but at a higher cost per BTU than in mild weather.
Do heat pumps work in cold climates?
Yes — cold-climate models are rated for operation well below freezing. The question is operating cost, not capability.
Put a number on it
By Yan Hausmann · Updated 2026-10-28